Another hurdle for Spy Machine
TELECOMS| Sept. 23, 2012, 4:17 p.m.
By Gregory Gondwe, Blantyre, Malawi
The High Court in Blantyre on Friday stopped the Malawi Communication Regulatory Authority (MACRA) from going ahead with the implementation of the Consolidated ICT Regulatory Management Systems (CIRMS) famed as the ‘Spy Machine’.
This ruling comes a year after the another judge who presided over the matter as a commercial case restrained MACRA from getting Call Details Records (CDRs) from the country’s telephone operators, as a requirement to have the machine operational.
And on Friday, High Court Judge Justice Healy Potani prohibited MACRA from going ahead with the installation of the machine because MACRA has no mandate, powers or jurisdiction to implement the CIRMS.
“It is unreasonable, [and] not necessary in an open and democratic society,” said Justice Potani who also said such an action is not recognised by international human rights standard.
Concerned citizens, Eric Sabwera and Hophmally Makande took the matter to court where they challenged the use of the machine to monitor and analyse all telecommunication traffic.
They also challenged the directive by MACRA to all telecommunication operators to provide it with subscribers CDRs.
In their argument, the two argued that the decision by MACRA was unreasonable, not backed by any law and would infringe upon their constitutional right to privacy.
Justice Potani ruled that MACRA has failed to satisfy six necessary requirements that the operation must be prescribed by law, reasonable, recognised by international human rights standards, necessary in an open and democratic society, of general application and must not negate the essential content of the right to privacy.
“The impression and implication I get is that the machine could be set up in such a manner that would make it capable of tapping the content of telecommunications traffic. One would tend to wonder, justifiably with suspicion, why MACRA would opt to use a system or gadget that has great potential of abuse,” ruled the Judge.
This was based on MACRA’s argument during the hearing when it said as a regulator; it has the right to monitor the performance of telecommunications service providers particularly on quality, efficiency and reliability of service and revenue generated.
However the judge squashed this argument by stating that he had very serious doubts that MACRA would really need caller details in order to monitor performance, quality of service or indeed revenue generated.
Since the machine was going to be used to access all call subscriber details, including what numbers a mobile phone had called, the judge declared that this was an invasion of people’s privacy.
“The machine has the potential to be abused as it had the capability to eavesdrop into people’s conversations, emails and text messages,” pointed out the Judge.
MACRA has since indicated that they are going to appeal against the ruling.
Director of Legal Services for MACRA James Kaphale said for the judgement which is that the machine has the capability to listen into a phone conversation and therefore it will be abused.
“The fact that we have a gun does not mean that we intend to shoot people with it,” argued Kaphale.
But in the event that they have lost the appeal stage, MACRA’s board will consult with govt on what to do with the machine.
Politicians and human rights activists led mass protest and challenged implementation of the ‘spy machine’ as it was meant to be snooping on people’s conversation, checking on people’s emails and texts which sent panic.
The country’s four operators, Malawi Telecommunication Limited (MTL), Telecom Networks of Malawi (TNM), Airtel Malawi and Access Communications Limited (ACL) also challenged MACRA on the machine.
In their submission MACRA argued that while the machine was capable of listening into people’s conversation, MACRA had no intention to use it for that purpose but only wanted information on calling numbers, dialled numbers, duration of calls, devices used and the call junction and location of the caller.
During his ruling Justice Potani referred to the first ruling in the commercial case of 2011 where the presiding judge ruled against MACRA.
“I would tend to agree that it is unreasonable and not necessary in an open and democratic society for subscribers call details to be laid bare wholesale,” said Justice Potani in agreement in the first ruling.
“The reliefs sought by the applicants are therefore granted and accordingly it is ordered that the respondent [MACRA] has no mandate, powers and jurisdiction to implement its decision and there it’s prohibited and restrained from implementing the decision,” said the judge.
President of Association of telecom Operators Saulos Chilima said as an industry, they have been saying all along that this machine does not add any value to anyone.
“We hope this judgement will put the matter to rest and that moves are made to recover the hard-earned millions of American dollars paid out as deposit for the machine,” said Chilima who is also Managing Director for Airtel Malawi.
MORE TELECOMS NEWS
Yes, Etisalat dragged us to court, says MTNMTN Nigeria has confirmed that it has been served with court papers based on a lawsuit filed by Emerging Markets Telecommunications Services Limited (Etisalat Nigeria) over the acquisition of Visafone, the only surviving code division multiple access (CDMA) operator in the country. Read More
Etisalat challenges MTN spectrum useEtisalat Nigeria says it has brought a legal action challenging MTN’s use of the 800MHZ spectrum following the acquisition of Visafone. Read More
NewTelco SA extends African footprint with dedicated Kenyan presenceThe Jasco Group has expanded the presence of NewTelco South Africa, a joint venture between the Jasco Group and NewTelco GMBH, into the East African region with a dedicated presence in Kenya. Read More
Facility closure to affect Ondo services, warns MTNMTN Nigeria has warned that the closure of its facilities in Ondo by the state government will negatively impact the quality of service in the state. Read More
Telcos threaten service blackout on states shutting BTSNigeria’s telecoms operators have threatened not to reopen any base transmission station (BTS) that were forcefully shut down by states. Read More
Neglect of CDMA a mistake, says NCC CEOThe Nigeria Communications Commission (NCC) has lamented the comatose state of the CDMA sector of the telecoms industry. Read More
Airtel introduces new UnlimiNet 20 daily bundleAirtel has introduced a new “UnlimiNet 20 bundle”, billed as the most affordable bundled offer for voice, SMS and data on the Airtel network. Read More
Safaricom opens new Narok retail shopSafaricom has set its sights on Narok County as it seeks to provide residents of the rapidly growing town with easier access to its wide range of products and services. Read More
Why we launched Mate 8, M2 Tablet: HuaweiChinese original equipment manufacturer Huawei has said it launched its two new flagship products, Mate 8 and M2 Tablet, to cater for the increasing mobile needs of consumers. Read More
FEATURED STORYViber Spreads Good Vibes in Africa with the introduction of public chats
Viber, one of the leading messaging and calling apps with more than 664 million unique users worldwide, has opened its latest social channel ‘Public Chats’ to partners in Africa and the Middle East.
BEST READ NEWS
IN DEPTHPoised for greater heights – Roshi Motman, AfricaCom CEO of the Year Winner
Roshi Motman is not your average CEO. Since taking up the reins as the first female CEO of Tigo Ghana in 2014, she has led the Tigo brand through a remarkable transformation.
COMPANY NEWSArbor Networks maintains leadership in IHS Infonetics Report on DDoS prevention appliances
Arbor Networks was identified once again as the top supplier of DDoS mitigation appliances overall, as well as in the Carrier, Enterprise and Mobile market segments, according ...