Another hurdle for Spy Machine
TELECOMS| Sept. 23, 2012, 4:17 p.m.
By Gregory Gondwe, Blantyre, Malawi
The High Court in Blantyre on Friday stopped the Malawi Communication Regulatory Authority (MACRA) from going ahead with the implementation of the Consolidated ICT Regulatory Management Systems (CIRMS) famed as the ‘Spy Machine’.
This ruling comes a year after the another judge who presided over the matter as a commercial case restrained MACRA from getting Call Details Records (CDRs) from the country’s telephone operators, as a requirement to have the machine operational.
And on Friday, High Court Judge Justice Healy Potani prohibited MACRA from going ahead with the installation of the machine because MACRA has no mandate, powers or jurisdiction to implement the CIRMS.
“It is unreasonable, [and] not necessary in an open and democratic society,” said Justice Potani who also said such an action is not recognised by international human rights standard.
Concerned citizens, Eric Sabwera and Hophmally Makande took the matter to court where they challenged the use of the machine to monitor and analyse all telecommunication traffic.
They also challenged the directive by MACRA to all telecommunication operators to provide it with subscribers CDRs.
In their argument, the two argued that the decision by MACRA was unreasonable, not backed by any law and would infringe upon their constitutional right to privacy.
Justice Potani ruled that MACRA has failed to satisfy six necessary requirements that the operation must be prescribed by law, reasonable, recognised by international human rights standards, necessary in an open and democratic society, of general application and must not negate the essential content of the right to privacy.
“The impression and implication I get is that the machine could be set up in such a manner that would make it capable of tapping the content of telecommunications traffic. One would tend to wonder, justifiably with suspicion, why MACRA would opt to use a system or gadget that has great potential of abuse,” ruled the Judge.
This was based on MACRA’s argument during the hearing when it said as a regulator; it has the right to monitor the performance of telecommunications service providers particularly on quality, efficiency and reliability of service and revenue generated.
However the judge squashed this argument by stating that he had very serious doubts that MACRA would really need caller details in order to monitor performance, quality of service or indeed revenue generated.
Since the machine was going to be used to access all call subscriber details, including what numbers a mobile phone had called, the judge declared that this was an invasion of people’s privacy.
“The machine has the potential to be abused as it had the capability to eavesdrop into people’s conversations, emails and text messages,” pointed out the Judge.
MACRA has since indicated that they are going to appeal against the ruling.
Director of Legal Services for MACRA James Kaphale said for the judgement which is that the machine has the capability to listen into a phone conversation and therefore it will be abused.
“The fact that we have a gun does not mean that we intend to shoot people with it,” argued Kaphale.
But in the event that they have lost the appeal stage, MACRA’s board will consult with govt on what to do with the machine.
Politicians and human rights activists led mass protest and challenged implementation of the ‘spy machine’ as it was meant to be snooping on people’s conversation, checking on people’s emails and texts which sent panic.
The country’s four operators, Malawi Telecommunication Limited (MTL), Telecom Networks of Malawi (TNM), Airtel Malawi and Access Communications Limited (ACL) also challenged MACRA on the machine.
In their submission MACRA argued that while the machine was capable of listening into people’s conversation, MACRA had no intention to use it for that purpose but only wanted information on calling numbers, dialled numbers, duration of calls, devices used and the call junction and location of the caller.
During his ruling Justice Potani referred to the first ruling in the commercial case of 2011 where the presiding judge ruled against MACRA.
“I would tend to agree that it is unreasonable and not necessary in an open and democratic society for subscribers call details to be laid bare wholesale,” said Justice Potani in agreement in the first ruling.
“The reliefs sought by the applicants are therefore granted and accordingly it is ordered that the respondent [MACRA] has no mandate, powers and jurisdiction to implement its decision and there it’s prohibited and restrained from implementing the decision,” said the judge.
President of Association of telecom Operators Saulos Chilima said as an industry, they have been saying all along that this machine does not add any value to anyone.
“We hope this judgement will put the matter to rest and that moves are made to recover the hard-earned millions of American dollars paid out as deposit for the machine,” said Chilima who is also Managing Director for Airtel Malawi.
MORE TELECOMS NEWS
Vodafone Ghana provides ‘live-chat’ platform for customersVodafone Ghana says it has launched an online ‘Live Chat’ and ‘Support Centre’ to enhance its range of customer care channels that offer timely and convenient response to customers’ queries. Read More
Juwah’s tenure at NCC endsDr. Eugene Juwah’s tenure as the Executive Vice Chairman of the Nigeria Communication Commission has come to an end. Read More
Etisalat sues MTN over anti-competitive practicesEtisalat has instituted legal action against Nigeria’s dominant operator, MTN, over practices it says threaten its business. Read More
Orange increases interest in the Moroccan operator Méditel with the acquisition of an additional 9%Fipar-Holding (the Moroccan Caisse de Dépôt et de Gestion group), FinanceCom and Orange signed the final documentation increasing Orange's interest in Méditel, the Moroccan telecommunications operator, in application of the agreements they signed in December 2010. Read More
Safaricom gives network assurance ahead of Obama visitSafaricom has assured its subscribers that minimal network disruptions shall be experienced during visit of US president Barack Obama. Read More
Airtel unveils next gen enterprise solution in GhanaAirtel Ghana says it is setting the new standard for Enterprise business solutions with the launch of its business oriented sub brand, Airtel Business. Read More
Tigo Africa Customer Operations Director visits GhanaThe Customer Operations Director for Tigo Africa, Ingeborg Nieuwenhuis, has just concluded a week-long visit to Ghana. Read More
Tigo reinforces security at cell sites due to battery theftTigo says it is determined to invest to ensure a reliable and stable network for its customers despite rampant cable cuts and increasing battery theft. Read More
MTN Ghana introduces Relationship ManagersSubscribers of MTN Ghana can now get any challenges resolved quickly and amicably, thanks to the introduction of Relationship Managers at MTN Ghana’s 82 customer service points across the country. Read More
FEATURED STORYKenyan SACCOS riding on innovation to attract customers
As confidence in mainstream banks remains low due to prohibitive interest rates, customers are embracing Savings and Credit Cooperatives (SACCO) as an alternative.
BEST READ NEWS
IN DEPTHAs curtain falls on MDGs, what next?
Dr. Bjorn Lomborg, president of the Copenhagen Consensus Centre, speaks to Biztechafrica about setting smart targets.